Are they proposing it as a yearly tax? That seems like the proposal is just for show. We should be working on implementing an inheritance tax if we want to be serious about taxing wealth.
How do you value something that was not sold? Some people can paint paintings worth millions others can paint the same painting and it’s worth less than the canvas. If you need to go through and value everything that everyone above a certain threshold has every single year you will get bogged down with accounting work. Especially since these people employ teams of accountants that will be deceiving you every step of the way. It’s much easier to do a one time big taxation event than a small recurring one (see Nate Erskine-Smith’s discussion on this). It’s also much fairer. While you are living you should be rewarded for high earnings, but when you pass your children did not earn that wealth.
Are they proposing it as a yearly tax? That seems like the proposal is just for show. We should be working on implementing an inheritance tax if we want to be serious about taxing wealth.
billionaires have a lifetime of 80+ years. At this rate, you’re not gonna tax Zuckerberg or Bezos in their, or your, lifetime.
Yeah, but just like capital gains, it doesn’t make sense to tax wealth until it is changing hands.
but why not?
How do you value something that was not sold? Some people can paint paintings worth millions others can paint the same painting and it’s worth less than the canvas. If you need to go through and value everything that everyone above a certain threshold has every single year you will get bogged down with accounting work. Especially since these people employ teams of accountants that will be deceiving you every step of the way. It’s much easier to do a one time big taxation event than a small recurring one (see Nate Erskine-Smith’s discussion on this). It’s also much fairer. While you are living you should be rewarded for high earnings, but when you pass your children did not earn that wealth.