Windows 10 is close to being dead now, with support ending this year. So why not try out Linux? Instead of getting a whole new system and having to deal with the increasing amount of AI junk and adverts in Windows 11.
Lots more data harvesting. Lots more AI. Lots more malware.
My partner isn’t tech savvy. I asked them to type “CPU-Z” into the task bar and instead of it opening the installed CPU-Z on their computer, the first suggested result was a download link for CPU-Z. They clicked it to download CPU-Z and got full-on AI-suggested malware that forced us to nuke their PC
As far as I can tell it’s mostly the TPM requirement and pushing more ads / AI nonsense.
You can easily avoid the latter by using the LTSC IoT version. I just bought a new (second hand) computer for TPM (my old one was very due for an upgrade).
With the IoT version it’s absolutely fine. Definitely an improvement over Windows 10. The only issue I’ve noticed is it doesn’t come with Windows Game bar or some nonsense so after you run games you’ll get a random dialog about there not being an app available to handle ms-gamelink URLs or something. You can just ignore it. I might fix it one day.
Pro version, install with English UK language, disable the crap once install is completed, takes less time than to fiddle with Linux to make it work like you want it to…
Anti-privacy by default, pushing AI slop that takes all your data, more than one improperly checked update rolled out that bricked many computers, shoving Ads everywhere…
Of course you could say these to not be strictly new, but it is a new level of enshittification way beyond what we used to know.
I actually wouldn’t mind upgrading to Windows 11, but I ran Microsoft’s compatibility tool and it told me I couldn’t. I only built my computer in late 2018, and have upgraded storage space since then. But it’s nowhere near old enough to need replacing the motherboard or processor.
Microsoft is just requiring an arbitrary hardware specification as an olive branch to their hardware manufacturer partners.
Many can’t upgrade to 11 and don’t want to buy a new device. They’ll believe it’s their only option unless told otherwise. It’s not necessarily a “Win11 is bad” or “Linux/BSD is better” scenario, just a “to keep using your current device which you paid for less than a decade ago, do the following”.
Times are hard and people shouldn’t be forced to buy new hardware because of the current monopolistic software companies’s latest money making scheme, especially when their old one works perfectly fine and the environment is going to suffer.
The big one is W11 now requires a TPM chip, so tons of computers will stop getting updates soon, with no way to upgrade.
And they keep getting worse with a bunch of annoyances, like more ads, trying to force ai, making it harder to avoid a microsoft account, and getting rid of ways to customize the desktop layout.
I will have to buy a new pc anyway soon, so I don’t mind that. But I understand the other reasons. I’m hoping I will find a way to customize the desktop, as it is important to me. Not to mention blocking ads.
With the steam deck proving that Linux gaming was not only possible but easy, I could remove gaming as a reason to keep windows, which meant the only thing I actually wanted windows for was an Adobe subscription that I hadn’t used in over a year. With windows fighting me the whole time, Linux got out of my way and let me use my own device how I wanted to. Which by the way sounds like I’m using it for something complicated or specialized but I’m not, I need it for web browsing, gaming, and light photo editing, that’s about it.
So that’s the positive case to move away from windows. The other side is that Windows is actively hostile to me as a user. I don’t want or need copilot. For starters I don’t have the hardware to really take advantage of it, and I don’t want it using power unnecessarily. I don’t want office 365, I don’t want OneDrive, I don’t want another UI on top of the 5 other UI frameworks that exist in windows which only serve to make it harder to change things to what I want. I don’t want to sign in using a Hotmail account I made when I was 12 and haven’t touched in years. I don’t want windows telling Microsoft how I use my own device. There’s some cool stuff in windows 11 like WSL which is awesome for me as a dev in my day job, but it’s not enough to keep me in a system that, by design and direction, is trying to lock me into it.
Xbox app is another example, where my game controllers sometimes work and most of the time don’t. Sometimes there’s cross play with steam, sometimes not. Sometimes even installing the game doesn’t work and I have to re-download the entire game again. Just bafflingly bad and costs me more than steam ever has. Ridiculous.
Gaming is the main reason I own a pc. I understand it’s possible on Linux, but is it as easy as on Windows? Not to mention, that I pirate most of my games.
I am contemplating switching to Linux, but I am too afraid, that I will run into something I didn’t realize windows is necessary for.
There are some games that don’t work or don’t work as well. Some anti-cheat systems don’t work but the website protondb.com will tell you how compatible specific games are. For some people that’s a deal breaker and that’s ok, hopefully as adoption increases the situation will get better. I was disappointed to find out that vermintide 2 doesn’t work for example.
No. I once accidentally installed the update, but immediately returned to 10, when I saw how it looks. But I imagine, with some settings and add-ons I can make it look like 10.
Windows Recall is one of their AI solutions they’re pushing onto people which would screenshot everything on your system in order to assist users in searching through previous desktop interactions and whatnot.
Security researchers are highly against the rollout of this ‘feature’ as it uses AI and the previous betas have shown that Microsoft is incapable of ensuring the prevention of abuse from malicious users.
Ex: a user entering in their credit card information for an online transaction would have that information stored as an indexable/searchable piece of information by a malicious outsider.
Microsoft has yet to show competance in their abilities to prevent the creation of such a wide attack surface.
The issue is not with the appearance. It’s the fact that microsoft keeps pushing AI into everything. The settings app is still shit and missing control panel functionality. There is more to say but these are the main issues afaik.
In addition to the front facing AI features, these days Windows 11 is less an operating system and more a ‘suck as much data about this person to train our AI models as we can get away with’.
Honest question. Is there some particular reason why people are against 11? Except the usual reasons people are against windows?
Edit: shoving AI down your throat
And this all besides all the other already present points to shit on Microsoft like the data collection
Lots more data harvesting. Lots more AI. Lots more malware.
My partner isn’t tech savvy. I asked them to type “CPU-Z” into the task bar and instead of it opening the installed CPU-Z on their computer, the first suggested result was a download link for CPU-Z. They clicked it to download CPU-Z and got full-on AI-suggested malware that forced us to nuke their PC
As far as I can tell it’s mostly the TPM requirement and pushing more ads / AI nonsense.
You can easily avoid the latter by using the LTSC IoT version. I just bought a new (second hand) computer for TPM (my old one was very due for an upgrade).
With the IoT version it’s absolutely fine. Definitely an improvement over Windows 10. The only issue I’ve noticed is it doesn’t come with Windows Game bar or some nonsense so after you run games you’ll get a random dialog about there not being an app available to handle ms-gamelink URLs or something. You can just ignore it. I might fix it one day.
Pro version, install with English UK language, disable the crap once install is completed, takes less time than to fiddle with Linux to make it work like you want it to…
Sounds like a lot more fiddling then just going to linux
Anti-privacy by default, pushing AI slop that takes all your data, more than one improperly checked update rolled out that bricked many computers, shoving Ads everywhere…
Of course you could say these to not be strictly new, but it is a new level of enshittification way beyond what we used to know.
I actually wouldn’t mind upgrading to Windows 11, but I ran Microsoft’s compatibility tool and it told me I couldn’t. I only built my computer in late 2018, and have upgraded storage space since then. But it’s nowhere near old enough to need replacing the motherboard or processor.
Microsoft is just requiring an arbitrary hardware specification as an olive branch to their hardware manufacturer partners.
2018 with parts from 2018? Check if your bios needs an update because it should work.
Many can’t upgrade to 11 and don’t want to buy a new device. They’ll believe it’s their only option unless told otherwise. It’s not necessarily a “Win11 is bad” or “Linux/BSD is better” scenario, just a “to keep using your current device which you paid for less than a decade ago, do the following”.
Times are hard and people shouldn’t be forced to buy new hardware because of the current monopolistic software companies’s latest money making scheme, especially when their old one works perfectly fine and the environment is going to suffer.
The big one is W11 now requires a TPM chip, so tons of computers will stop getting updates soon, with no way to upgrade.
And they keep getting worse with a bunch of annoyances, like more ads, trying to force ai, making it harder to avoid a microsoft account, and getting rid of ways to customize the desktop layout.
I will have to buy a new pc anyway soon, so I don’t mind that. But I understand the other reasons. I’m hoping I will find a way to customize the desktop, as it is important to me. Not to mention blocking ads.
With the steam deck proving that Linux gaming was not only possible but easy, I could remove gaming as a reason to keep windows, which meant the only thing I actually wanted windows for was an Adobe subscription that I hadn’t used in over a year. With windows fighting me the whole time, Linux got out of my way and let me use my own device how I wanted to. Which by the way sounds like I’m using it for something complicated or specialized but I’m not, I need it for web browsing, gaming, and light photo editing, that’s about it.
So that’s the positive case to move away from windows. The other side is that Windows is actively hostile to me as a user. I don’t want or need copilot. For starters I don’t have the hardware to really take advantage of it, and I don’t want it using power unnecessarily. I don’t want office 365, I don’t want OneDrive, I don’t want another UI on top of the 5 other UI frameworks that exist in windows which only serve to make it harder to change things to what I want. I don’t want to sign in using a Hotmail account I made when I was 12 and haven’t touched in years. I don’t want windows telling Microsoft how I use my own device. There’s some cool stuff in windows 11 like WSL which is awesome for me as a dev in my day job, but it’s not enough to keep me in a system that, by design and direction, is trying to lock me into it.
Xbox app is another example, where my game controllers sometimes work and most of the time don’t. Sometimes there’s cross play with steam, sometimes not. Sometimes even installing the game doesn’t work and I have to re-download the entire game again. Just bafflingly bad and costs me more than steam ever has. Ridiculous.
Gaming is the main reason I own a pc. I understand it’s possible on Linux, but is it as easy as on Windows? Not to mention, that I pirate most of my games.
I am contemplating switching to Linux, but I am too afraid, that I will run into something I didn’t realize windows is necessary for.
There are some games that don’t work or don’t work as well. Some anti-cheat systems don’t work but the website protondb.com will tell you how compatible specific games are. For some people that’s a deal breaker and that’s ok, hopefully as adoption increases the situation will get better. I was disappointed to find out that vermintide 2 doesn’t work for example.
I have no idea on the pirating side.
Have you seen what microsoft is pushing on 11??
No. I once accidentally installed the update, but immediately returned to 10, when I saw how it looks. But I imagine, with some settings and add-ons I can make it look like 10.
Windows Recall is one of their AI solutions they’re pushing onto people which would screenshot everything on your system in order to assist users in searching through previous desktop interactions and whatnot.
Security researchers are highly against the rollout of this ‘feature’ as it uses AI and the previous betas have shown that Microsoft is incapable of ensuring the prevention of abuse from malicious users.
Ex: a user entering in their credit card information for an online transaction would have that information stored as an indexable/searchable piece of information by a malicious outsider.
Microsoft has yet to show competance in their abilities to prevent the creation of such a wide attack surface.
The issue is not with the appearance. It’s the fact that microsoft keeps pushing AI into everything. The settings app is still shit and missing control panel functionality. There is more to say but these are the main issues afaik.
In addition to the front facing AI features, these days Windows 11 is less an operating system and more a ‘suck as much data about this person to train our AI models as we can get away with’.