Mastodon

Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?

  • 669 Posts
  • 596 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle





  • This was one of the really unique episodes that defies description, and frankly I’m impressed you got as much mileage out of it as you did. I don’t think I have much to add. To revisit the comparison I made yesterday, it does share some things in common with one of my favourites, “Demons of the Punjab”, in its otherworldly vibes.

    Edit: Actually, no. It’s not just otherworldly vibes. It’s that plus an exploration of a culture that’s not my own.

    The Fugitive Doctor! For all of thirty seconds!

    The little line/quip about her story maybe being complete one day made me chuckle - and of course, the Doctor’s story being neverending is part of the resolution.

    There is some of the same subject matter and deftness here as in some of Neil Gaiman’s better work — and that’s all we need say about him.

    Yeeeeeeeeah, I had the same thought. This sort of subject matter is something that Gaiman - scandal noted - excelled at.

    And I have to agree, this season just might be an “all killer, no filler” season to rival the Ten/Donna season or Eleven’s first season.




  • Instead they showed him as normal, then suddenly revealed him to be horrible, and did a little flashback.

    I mean he was kind of horrible from the very first scene, with the “miss” bullshit and his comment about girls being bad at math. He was never showed as normal.

    But, then they included the racism, but only in a “dream sequence”? That both acknowledges that the racism was massive in the 1950s, but somehow simultaneously pretends that in the “real world” it didn’t exist?

    Again, no. They acknowledged that the diner was segregated - it just so happened that the employee and grieving mother didn’t care. There were people who weren’t fans of segregation at that time.

    But, he has never taunted someone who was captured before. Much more doctorish would have been to attempt to reform him.

    “The Family of Blood” anyone? “The Christmas Invasion”?